Abu Muqawama retains its autonomy and the views and beliefs expressed within the blog do not reflect those of CNAS. Abu Muqawama retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.
It's probably not even worth counting how many times one side of a conflict has portrayed the increasing violence of its foes as a "last gasp". The Taliban in Afghanistan has been gasping since about 2005, and the surge in attacks about a year after the invasion of Iraq was a last gasp right to the point militants butchered themselves to the very edge of a civil war. Londonstani's no expert on military history, but if semi-remembered school lessons serve him right, Goebbels was going on about the allies gasping their last as they marched in his direction. And of course, there was Comical Ali...
And now its the turn of the militants in Waziristan. Pakistan's Chief of Army Staff, Gen Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, told the prime minister today that the army's operation in the north, known as Rah-e-Najat, had "broken the terrorists' back". This comes a day after a suicide bomber killed 35 people after detonating in front of a bank in Rawalpindi, a few kms from the capital. Far removed from the actual events, it's easy to become inured to the seemingly endless and horrifically predictable litany of destruction. This BBC story gives a sense of the human tragedy of this latest episode.
"Local people said the area was absolutely packed with people at the time the explosion took place. One man came rushing to search for his father who had been going to pick up his pension. That man has not yet been found. His son said he was making a direct appeal to the government: 'Please, save our lives.'"
On the same day as the Rawalpindi attack, two suicide bombers in a car wounded 25 people when they blew themselves up after police stopped them trying to get into Lahore.
There is a report in the local press that Taliban commanders were intercepted plotting a huge 2,500kg explosion in Lahore. At first glance, this sounds overly ambitious on their part. However, such reports also predicted the attacks in Peshawar and the targetting of educational institutions. In that light, the premature explosions on the outskirts of Lahore take on an even more worrying dimension... Are there many other such explosive laden cars getting through to Lahore?
Further north, things are so bad the UN has pulled out its foreign workers out of NWFP. In Islamabad, the sense of fear is all encompassing. Second guessing what sort of areas militants might target has replaced second guessing who their "real" paymasters might be. A trip to some of Islamabad's usually popular evening haunts leaves you with a huge amunt of space to yourself. People don't seem to be too reassured by the blue-cad security guards who wave around a beeping electronic wand as you pass them before collapsing back on their chairs.
But if Islamabadies and Lahories are staying indoors out of fear, conditions for civilians in the conflict zone of South Waziristan must be much, much worse. Unfortunately, though, there is still little way to assess how the fighting is going. Which means there's no way to know whether the army's actions are giving birth to a future militant threat or effectively dealing with the present one.
The army has taken journalists up to the front, or near it. In this story, TIME reports on the fighting in the Sherwangai Valley. The army says that amongst all the laptops and weapons, it also found the passport of one of the 9/11 plotters. One Islamabad taxi driver's response to this was; "The army is trying to tell the Americans what it thinks they want to hear." But then, Islamabad taxi drivers, in Londonstani's experience, are a pretty cynical bunch.
In Londonstani's opinion Saleem Shehzad of Asia Times has some of the best contacts in FATA and should be listened to. This is how he sees the fighting in Waziristan:
Hakimullah Mehsud of the TTP, according to Asia Times Online contacts, has apparently adopted a strategy that will not expend too many resources on protecting the Mehsud area. Instead, he aims to spread chaos by attacking security personnel in the cities.
The same contacts say that when thousands of people left South Waziristan last week under the military's directives, a majority of the militants melted away to the Shawal region, situated at the crossroads of South Waziristan, Afghanistan and North Waziristan, besides going to Pakistani cities.
A very limited force is entrenched in the Mehsud tribal area, and by all accounts it is putting up fierce resistance.
By marching into South Waziristan, the military has taken something of a gamble as it is highly unlikely to eliminate the militant threat. Indeed, the past seven or so years have shown that after any operation against militants, the militants have always gained from the situation. By the same token, the militants don't have the capacity to permanently control ground beyond their areas in South Waziristan and North Waziristan.
...there are signals that the Taliban in the Swat area in North-West Frontier Province are regrouping after being pushed back by the army this year. It is likely that by the time the snow chokes major supply routes, the Taliban will have seized all lost ground in the Swat Valley.
Don’t forget about General
Don’t forget about General William Westmoreland, MACV commander in Vietnam,who famously stated that he saw the light at the end of the tunnel. Unfortunately, he didn’t notice that the light was attached to the front of a speeding train that was headed right for him.
We’ll see how this one turns out.
Thank you so much for your reporting over the past couple of weeks. Your on-the-ground evaluations and reports have been most helpful in my unending quest to make sense out of this entire mess — a subject which I fear I may die of old age before mastering.
Londonstani - wondering if
Londonstani - wondering if you can give your thoughts on the recent attacks such as the market blast that killed civilians and the recent operation manual that the Taliban has handed out that expressly advised against the wanton death of civilians.
The Taliban and their allies have seemed canny enough fighters in the last few years but this just seems to be at odds with a strategy designed to enhance their relationship with a civilians population
"Londonstani - wondering if
"Londonstani - wondering if you can give your thoughts on the recent attacks such as the market blast that killed civilians and the recent operation manual that the Taliban has handed out that expressly advised against the wanton death of civilians. "
Was just thinking the same thing myself. Although I haven't kept up with all the attacks, it did seem for a while there that they were targetting Pak police and intel with their bombings. I'm sure this bank blast probably isn't the first departure, but it is strikingly on the other side of the line.
ps. A big hello to our visitors who never miss a chance to attribute deaths of coalition personnel to the new ROE. I'm sure the fact that even the Taliban, in the course of endorsing suicide bombings, acknowledges that operations need to be changed to avoid civilian casualties at all costs has made no impression on you as to just how fringe your position is.
To David Sutton:
To David Sutton:
"Londonstani - wondering if you can give your thoughts on the recent attacks such as the market blast that killed civilians and the recent operation manual that the Taliban has handed out that expressly advised against the wanton death of civilians."
Which Taliban do you mean? the manual was brought out by the Afghan Taliban, who have explicitly distanced themselves from their Pakistani cousins the TTP (Tehrik e Taliban Pakistan) and their war against the Pakistan military. The TTP has also denied that they have carried out the bombings in Peshawer market ,as well as the Islamic University campus for women. However nobody actually beleives their disclaimers. They would still like to hit the security forces but times are tough, and its easier to get the soft targets with maximum impact. Anyways, it was expected they would hit soft targets once the mili. operation in S. waziristan got underway.
The Pakistani army hasn't
The Pakistani army hasn't broken Tehrik-i Taliban Pakistan's back. It's their usual spin. The TTP leader is apparently quite the tactician. Pictorial Profile of Hakimullah Mehsud
Add your comment