Abu Muqawama: Post

Abu Muqawama retains its autonomy and the views and beliefs expressed within the blog do not reflect those of CNAS. Abu Muqawama retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.

Pakistan's New Year resolutions

The News on Sunday newspaper printed a list of "obsessions" Pakistan could do without in 2010. It's sort of like a list of New Year resolutions. But away from politics (as much as anything can be in Pakistan) it's a fun, alternative look at Pakistani society from the inside.

Read the whole thing here:

Londonstani's favourite is this:

"Membership of one Ummah

We strongly believe in the idea. Ummah, one single body that goes beyond the considerations of borders, tribes, castes and nationhood... It is binding upon us to help Muslims wherever they are. We in this country are more concerned about the problems and miseries of our fellow brethren from Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine, Lebanon, Sudan, Chechnya and Kashmir rather than those living close-by. Problems faced by Muslims in these countries form the subject matter of sermons of our clergy. One can hardly find prayer leaders talking about the problems of Muslims living in Pakistan. Ironically, the Ummah seems equally oblivious about Pakistan."

Well, it's between this and the one on sex.

 

Pakistan, society

15 comments

you can't ever go wrong w/

you can't ever go wrong w/ sex.

One can hardly find prayer

One can hardly find prayer leaders talking about the problems of Muslims living in Pakistan. Ironically, the Ummah seems equally oblivious about Pakistan."

It is better to give than receive.....

Roll the clock back about 60 years, except a couple (like the discussion of India), American obsessions were simular. Think today, you would have to look to the right-of-center to find the same obsessions were home is supreme, sex is for marriage (male/female), root of evil comes from somewhere else, relatives expect new relatives, and sex is something that is done behind closed doors.

Not sure the 60's were good for America, a lot would disagree with that statement. We lost a lot of lessons learned from the great depression. Value of a dollar was lost in the "me" generation. Now we have too much and people "flip" homes rather than raise a family in them.

Reminds me of the tail of a man with one shirt.....

A man could only afford one shirt. Each day he woke up took his neatly folded shirt off its shelf and put it on to go to work. At the end of the day, he took off his shirt, washed and dried it, folded it and placed it on the shelf for the next day. This went on until one day, he decided that he could afford two shirts. With two shirts he would never have to worry about washing and folding each day. At the end of the day, he would leave his shirt uncared for. He no longer cared about his shirts.

Having more is not always better, we forget what it takes to get to where we are.

Don't worry Zak. We'll

Don't worry Zak. We'll have less, starting with the lesson that our dollars have become valueless due to overprinting.

Uh...our society could do with a little less public sexuality. Your internets can confirm this for you, or what we call music, or TV...etc, etc. I don't want the burqua, I just want porn to be something secret and shameful. They have too much shame, we have none in the popular culture. Or seemingly in our elites.

BTW the purpose of sex is in fact to procreate the species. Just sayin. Nature just made it fun to move things along.

@Fnord, or any other

@Fnord, or any other fans...

3d White House Party Crasher found...

"Carlos Allen, the publisher and owner of Hush Magazine..."

Hush ?!?

On the quiet, very QT and very Hush Hush...

Elf/J.E.Fan: Lol. The ghost

Elf/J.E.Fan: Lol. The ghost of Howard Hughes... Wonder if Pete Bondurant is hanging around...? Now we know who has been leading the birthers, at least.

I like the food one.

I like the food one. Reminded me of a Pakistani friend who once described Pakistani wedding as everybody going crazy and rushing to the free food almost fighting over it. As the weddings were often public people who weren't actually friends with the married or anything would come there just to gorge in the food, so they actually made laws against having food at weddings in public places as whole comunities would all go to someones wedding dinner forcing poor families to have huge dinners they couldn't really pay for!

Don't know if he exaggerated a bit but that's what he told me.

On our email group, we have

On our email group, we have had a fair amount of discussion about coming events in Pakistan. The latest being Dr. Manzur Ejaz's opinion piece today (http://wichaar.com/news/294/ARTICLE/18179/2010-01-06.html)
in which he has unequivocally stated that the army-jihadi nexus is history and all jihadi parties will gradually be eliminated by the armed forces. An unstated corrollary of this hypothesis is that the state will actually survive and stabilize and all the "worst case scenarios" will fail to materialize.
I just happened to have a conversation with a Pakistani physician who just returned from a trip to Islamabad and he vehemently rejected this theory. I will present his argument and some thoughts of my own and look forward to your comments.
First, some background. This physician used to be a PMLN supporter as well as a Pak army supporter, strongly anchored in traditional orthodox Islam and from an upper-middle class family with "traditional values", not overtly westernized and certainly not secular in outlook.
Here is an outline of his argument:
1. Pakistan is an Islamic nation, created in the name of Islam.
2. The state's wrong policies since the time of General Zia have created a jihadi menace (this was a surprising statement coming from him).
3. The corrupt ruling elite has wrecked all institutions and completely failed in governance. The people are totally fed up and losing all hope of improvement.
4. The army is now trying to control these jihadis on behalf of the United States, but the army itself is largely or partly jihadi and no army can win a war if it is divided against itself.
5. The people see the army fighting against fellow muslims on behalf of America and intensely resent this action. They also see their own condition becoming more and more miserable and if this goes on, they will throw in their lot with the jihadis, who are fighting in the name of Islam and who are not corrupt.
6. America wants to destroy Pakistan and it is likely that all this is being stage managed by the US, who "wants pakistan to fight their war".
I said: "dont you think the army is strong enough to eventually win this fight against the jihadis". He said this army is a mercenary army and is infiltrated with Jihadi sympathizers. They cannot win against the Jihadis.
When I said, OK, so are you saying the jihadis will win against the army? He answered "no, they cannot defeat the army. Instead, Pakistan will break up and each part will go its separate way. That is what America wants."
I asked him HOW the breakup would occur? who would run each resulting component. He answered that he does not know, but this cannot last.

My comments:
I tend to agree with Dr. Ejaz. I think the army has no choice. It was a terrible mistake to create free standing armies of jihadis in the first place (what sane state has ever done that? what were they thinking when dozens of training camps were being set up all across the country and Masood Azhar and company were going around with escorts of armed men on pickup trucks? what was the plan? I already know the answer: there was no plan in the mind of the "secular" morons like Musharraf. They were just being their usual idiotic selves and were being made total fools by the jihadis like General Mahmud and General Gul and so on. But I ask the question to encourage all of you to spend a few minutes thinking about this. WTF was the army thinking and doesnt this deserve a real inquiry and several court martials?). But by now, even our generals must have realized what a mess they have made and know that this is not sustainable.
I also think the arguments presented by my friend are an indication that the belief that Pakistan is about to fall apart and the army will lose this battle are based on false premises and confused thinking. The pessimistic view reflects the (carefully manufactured) confusion of the chattering classes and not a systematic analysis of the facts on the ground.
But I also think that these confused statements (blaming the jihadis, General Zia, the CIA and everyone else in almost mutually exclusive theories) are an indication of what a tremendous job lies ahead of the army high command and how poorly they have managed the "information war" until now. Once again, I think the explanation has less to do with any clever scheme of having their jihad and eating it too, and more to do with the limited abilities of the high command and their desire to avoid (at all costs, even the cost of efficient handling of the war on terror) any discussion of how they created this mess and who the enemy is. Instead, they prefer to keep people confused with CIA-Jew-Freemason-Hindu conspiracies and any other story that comes to mind...anything but the truth that their own creations have brought Pakistan to this pass. The other driver behind this nonsense is their desire to hold on to "the commanding heights" of the state, even if they have to imperil the functioning of national institutions in a time of war to do so. On this, I differ with Dr. Ejaz, who beleives the army is actually trying to strengthen civilian institutions to save the state. I think he underestimates how totally the PMA mindset hates civilian politics and politicians and how exalted an opinion they have of their own ability to run everything from credit rating agencies to the railways.
I would make an analogy with the US civil war. A Dr. Ejaz in 1861 would have confidently predicted (on the basis of rational analysis of economic realities and the direction of historical trends) that the North was going to win the civil war and the Union would be preserved. Not only that, slavery would be abolished and the entire slave-owning economy overhauled and converted to more modern lines. That is exactly what eventually happened. But this 1861 Dr. Ejaz may not have known how close fought the thing would be, how long and hard the war would turn out to be, how terrible a slaughter it would cause...and even this imaginary Dr. Ejaz might have had second thoughts about his predictions when Lee was marching around Pennsylvania.....I think we are in for some very bad times in Pakistan as well.

I agree with most comments

I agree with most comments here regarding America's intentions on my beloved Pakistan! I agree and want to add my veiw ? I belive the US not only has an eveil eye on Pakistan's nuclear system? THERE PLANNING BIG THINGS! They want to liberate karachi and control it's port for business around asia and the middle east etc, it wants to break-up and make bases in the gas/oil rich Bulochistan, where they can find route into Iran and the middle east. They would also want to liberate Pakistan's NWFP by creating 15 small countries and control them by putting puppets such as Karzai and Zardari in charge? PAKISTAN WAKE-UP NOW PLZ!!! Eat grass and drink water? But don't except Mr Holbrookes US dollars - show the AMERICANS the door NOW !!! The US were never our friends? Going by history they have always tricked Pakistan and let us down in the favour of India and are still doing it ? They are making India stronger day by day by investing business in that country and giving them nuclear energy etc and much much more. What are we getting in contrast a few dollars for fighting their poxy war on terror what is costing us much more than the aid package that they are giving us and our precious brave army who are dying. There only destroying and making us weaker everyday compared to our enemy India who are there true friends in south asia ! PAKISTAN ZINDABAD (LONG LIVE PAKISTAN)

One more misconception

One more misconception usually you may not find recruited that can be played student soccer if you don’t have an astounding spotlight gucci bags video. A great gucci outlet online number of youthful soccer competitors around authentic nfl jerseys wholesale gucci outlet find discouraged because they imagine they have a better spotlight video or perhaps bundled amounts whenever they are going to employ a chance on having recruited to get student soccer. Whilst both of the items could be great, you’ll find a few some other means you’ll be able to impress your instructors. A pair of items that will spoil a group are usually weak perceptions and harmful do the job ethic - hence, irrespective of precisely how skilled you might be, in case a guru can feel you might be likely to deliver your group down, they don’t sponsor an individual.

I agree with your point,

I agree with your point, please share with us more good articles.1993 Buick Apollo AC Compressor

Add your comment

CNAS retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <hr><blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Search