Abu Muqawama: Post

Abu Muqawama retains its autonomy and the views and beliefs expressed within the blog do not reflect those of CNAS. Abu Muqawama retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.

Buy This Book. Now.

While home in Tennessee this weekend, I finished (and enjoyed) this book and this book. More on both later. But as soon as I started Matt Gallagher's new memoir, Kaboom, while waiting on my plane to depart from the airport in Chattanooga, I was hooked. This may well be the best memoir to have been written about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Why? Because it captures something I have never really seen captured all that well in memoirs -- how the constant suck of war is intertwined with the never-ended stream of hilarity that takes place in a tight-knit combat arms platoon. Kaboom is laugh-out-loud funny. And brutal. Buy it.

Books

53 comments

I followed Kaboom while I

I followed Kaboom while I was getting ready to deploy. It was easily the best written military blog I've ever read. Right behind it was the war on big tobacco for different reasons. It was devastating when he had to take it down. I can't wait for this book to be waiting for me in the mailbox when I get home from work.

I would love to buy this

I would love to buy this book NOW as you demand, however, I lack a time machine or the critical mass of clout needed to approximate a time machine. So me and the other lesser mortals will have to be satisfied with a pre-order and mere thoughts of reading this book at some nebulous point in the future.

In all seriousness it sounds like a great book and I am looking forward to reading it.

did you visit rossville

did you visit rossville while down there? why are there no sidewalks there?

Must be nice to get an early

Must be nice to get an early copy...

You may pre-order it now and

You may pre-order it now and we will deliver it to you when it arrives.
Ships from and sold by Amazon.com. Gift-wrap available.

Abu Muq, I know you've quit

Abu Muq,
I know you've quit your daily blogging in favor of real work, but could you elaborate a little? Would you compare this with Generation Kill?

I know you quit regularly

I know you quit regularly blogging in favor of real work, but could you elaborate a little? Does this book compare to Generation Kill?

i got my hands on an

i got my hands on an advanced copy as well, and I'd say it compares favorably to Generation Kill ... less invasion destruction, more COIN confusion ... and written by one of our own instead of a journalist. totally agree with A.M.'s assessment. And stop the yapping about "having" to pre-order! It's only a month away, for crissakes.

I thought the blog was

I thought the blog was pretty good content-wise, notwithstanding its stylistic tics. However, the post that ultimately got him shut down, the whine-fest about being promoted to XO really rubbed me the wrong way. It seems incredibly myopic and arrogant for him to believe he was so indispensable to his platoon. Seems to me that his PSG, equipped with at least a decade of experience as an 11B (as well as the training he presumably obtained at BNCOC and ANCOC) was fully capable of taking up whatever slack was incurred by replacing a 1LT with a butter-bar. Even more generally, it seems to me that an LT isn't put in a PL billet for whatever value he brings to the table on account of his 4-year degree and completion of OBC. Rather, I always thought that the PL job was primarily on-the-job training to prepare officers for the work they do as CO's, XO's, and staff. The Army needed Gallagher elsewhere. To refuse was nothing less than petulant. If he wanted a life on the line, he should have enlisted.

Maybe my reading was colored by my experience as a former NCO, who had a shitty PL (though I don't have any beef with officers per se). Any officers want to offer a different perspective? I recognize that many of you probably found your PL years the most enjoyable, but do you really think you brought much to the platoon that an E-7 couldn't provide? Am I off-base in characterizing it as nothing more than on-the-job training?

A PL's role in combat is

A PL's role in combat is very different than a PL's role in garrison and training. Back in garrison, yeah, a PL is doing on-the-job training. But down-range, especially in the COE, a good PL makes all the difference in the world.

As for Gallagher - my recollection isn't that he objected to being replaced with a butterbar, its not they weren't going to replace him at all. And there was the whole underlying thing of his superiors making him XO as a way of telling him to stay in the Army... it was tough to say, those last posts were very vague. I gather the book will add some clarity to this discussion. Junior officers there for the ride and experience, rather than a career, tend not to have a macro "do what the Army says" mentality, for good and for ill.

COE? Don't remember that

COE? Don't remember that acronym...Engineers? I don't suppose you'd be willing to elaborate on how a good PL makes a difference? What tasks exactly? My experience was downrange, and maybe my PL was doing useful things I didn't see, but I'm not convinced.

wow. current operating

wow. current operating environment.

and if you don't know what tasks your PL was doing, or supposed to be doing, i don't know what to tell you. perhaps he wasn't the problem.

I can think of many tasks

I can think of many tasks that my PL was doing or supposed to be doing (some of which I did for him). What I can't think of are any tasks that he was doing or supposed to be doing that my PSG couldn't do or didn't sometimes do. That is to say, I can't think of anything he did that "made a world of difference." Which is precisely what I asked you to elaborate on. Again, I didn't ask what a PL does. I asked what a good PL does that makes a world of difference.

Look, guy, I don't know that much about what happens in the officer corps, I was a jr. NCO. I'm asking you to enlighten me. I was an E-5, served for only 2.5 years. Notably, I did my job well enough to get promoted that quickly. Forgive me for not knowing a frackin' acronym; lord knows there are a million of them, and new ones crop up all the time. Also, COE was probably a bit above my pay grade.

You've given me a conclusory statement and an ad hominem attack. If you can't elaborate beyond that, I don't know what to tell you. I've known good officers and I've known poor ones. Your defensive and personal response doesn't convince me you belong in the former category. Doesn't mean you belong in the latter, but I think a good officer would welcome the opportunity to educate a (former) young NCO as to the proper role of the officer corps.

I've read a lot of the

I've read a lot of the recent post-9/11 war memoirs, and none of them have been funny so far. I'm waiting for this one.

@ the guy who said this was written by "one of our own" - Soldiers aren't as impartial as journalists, and their work isn;'t as interesting or honest. Compare "Generation Kill" to "One Bullet Away" and tell me which account better represents the same invasion. You'll choose "Generation kill" every time. Plus, there have been dozens of war memoirs written since 9/11. Dozens.

'the never-ended stream of

'the never-ended stream of hilarity'

Yes, absolutely! That was my big problem with The Good Soldiers, an otherwise brilliant account. Nobody seemed to be having a good time! I've never been in really serious combat, but I know enough about military life to know that much of it is achingly funny, at least if you're an enlisted man.

That comes across much better in The Only Thing Worth Dying for, which I am presently enjoying. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

'some nebulous point in the

'some nebulous point in the future'

March 23. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

This seems like a really

This seems like a really interesting book that I look forward to reading. I really am very impressed with this awesome selection. I work for a data recovery company and I get the chance to read through out the day. This is something that is really amazing to me. Thanks

This is an informative site.

This is an informative site. I would like to surf it all for taking into consideration testking 220-702 and its associated statements. Because testking 70-642 is very illustrious and in command now a days. So I am incisive for high-quality information about testking 350-030 and testking 640-863 at every site. And I should get fine resource soon.

This is a wonderful book that

This is a wonderful book that I really am thinking about purchasing. I really think this is very awesome and I hope to continue to learn more from your experience. Thanks Olivia Watson - Drainage Coventry Designer Manager

This was a really interesting

This was a really interesting book. I just read a few passages but I think I will get it soon. There are some really interesting stories there and I think we can all learn a little from this. Please keep up the great work. Thanks Brooke Maya - Used Car Values Expert

This was a really great book

This was a really great book that I really do appreciate. This is really very awesome to me. Pleasekeep up the great work. I really do appreciate this so much. Thanks Lauren Hither - Verizon FIOS Deals Expert

Wow great site! Very

Wow great site! Very informative. I am always looking for interesting things to read up on! Thanks Sydney Gibbs from
Live Nude Chat

Very new to me, but

Very new to me, but interesting. I did not realize that the Internet was based both on all the work done by groud computer scientists, such as the Unicode standard. It defines a consistent way of encoding multilingual text, and without the exchange of text data internationally could not occur Virus protection free 7.

I've been very surprised by

I've been very surprised by this great information. I've been a fan of this website for a very long time and really I can not wait to learn more about your expierence. Olivia Watson Thnaks Driving jobs London 7

I've been very surprised by

I've been very surprised by this great information. I've been a fan of this website for a very long time and really I can not wait to learn more about your expierence. Olivia Watson Thnaks Driving jobs London 7

I've been very surprised by

I've been very surprised by this great information. I've been a fan of this website for a very long time and really I can not wait to learn more about your expierence. Olivia Watson Thnaks Driving jobs London 7

Blogs are always the main

Blogs are always the main source of accurate information and to ensure a comfortable results, you can get immediate and reliable information, which will definitely help you in every area of your concern. I am a doctoral student in the testking ccnp IT and HR testking CISM. These days I do to prepare various online testking CISSP certifications and found testking mcdba and ccna bootcamp is the best source of help, which ensures 100% authentic materials. I also spend more time on the internet, listen to music and games. After my exams, I would like to join the group.

Thank you! I love this site.

Thank you! I love this site. There is always interesting and informative information. Thank you. Sierra Romesburg from
Sex Toys

Thanks for the site. I really

Thanks for the site. I really look forward to reading your blogs. I find them very education and informative. Keep up the great work. Donald Pagano from Green Janitorial Supplies

Thanks for the great

Thanks for the great information. You site has a lot of great articles everyone should read. Thank you for the articles Gabrielle Onita from Compensation

wow that is a lot of intents

wow that is a lot of intents from a lot of different people. I find that posting my daily intent gives me motivation to get it done. Thanks for the support, everyone in the Intent.com community! regards Virus protection free

Like you site. I'm very

Like you site. I'm very interested in what you offer here. Thanks and keep up the great work. I look forward too reading more! Fred McKenzie from Methane Detectors

This was a great article that

This was a great article that I really have enjoyed so much. Hopefully I can really learn from this book and help others. I really appreciate this description. Thanks Vanessa Clark - Nutritional Supplements expert

I really enjoy the site.

I really enjoy the site. Great articles all the time, very informative. I really like your site! Keep up the great work and I look forward to reading more. Isabel Jennings from Web Development Leeds

I really enjoy the site.

I really enjoy the site. Great articles all the time, very informative. I really like your site! Keep up the great work and I look forward to reading more. Isabel Jennings from Web Development Leeds

Love this article. Very cool

Love this article. Very cool site. Thank you for the article which I appreciate. It was very informative. Catherine Hurrigan from Flyer Design

Thank you for your tips, I

Thank you for your tips, I checked out Kaboom, bought it and I'm reading it right now, it's great!
Dating websites

A great article with some

A great article with some important insights. It gets you thinking about what the future might bring. Thanks. Commercial mortgage calculator

A great article with some

A great article with some important insights. It gets you thinking about what the future might bring. Thanks. Commercial mortgage calculator

I actually read the book and

I actually read the book and it is great. Hope to have a chance to talk about it some time.
Berber carpet

Nice site! Thanks for the

Nice site! Thanks for the article! I look forward to reading more! It was very informative. I appreciate the work you do! Keep Up the good work. Cassi from Genever

Thanks a lot for yet another

Thanks a lot for yet another first-rate article. I am always looking at for super WordPress secrets to recommend to my own readers. Thank you for creating this article. It’s precisely what I was searching for. Truly marvelous post….
魔域私服

Yes, absolutely! That was my

Yes, absolutely! That was my big problem with the good soldier, an otherwise brilliant account. Nobody seemed to be having a good time! I've never been in combat seriously, internet marketing services.but I know enough about military life to know that much of it is painfully funny, at least if you are a soldier. Home Security Cameras

Very new to me, but

Very new to me, but interesting. I did not realize that the Internet is based both on all the work done by computer scientists groud, such as the Unicode standard.Best Binoculars Under 100.It defines a consistent way of encoding multilingual text, and without the exchange of text data internationally could not occur..

Eclipse of the Sunnis: Power,

Eclipse of the Sunnis: Power, Exile, and Upheaval in the Middle East is a great read to undestand the current issues on the middle east. Highly recommended to every reader trying to understand the politics and investment of the middle east.

I totally agree with you.I

I totally agree with you.I was glad to find this site.I want to thank you application development for this great read! No doubt enjoying every bit of it and I have set to see new stuff you post. Thanks for sharing, along with her blog ……

Article is very nicely

Article is very nicely written and I am happy to find so many useful information here in the post, thanks for sharing it here. I hope you will adding more !

buy spice

If you are in search of a

If you are in search of a modern but budget-friendly tool to promote your products on point-of-sale areas, then try investing on digital photo frames. These digital photo frames are more eye-catching than the conventional posters or brochures. They can call the attention of your buyers specially if you get one of Nix digital photo frames with the motion sensor. These Hu-Motion digital photo frames by Nix will automatically turn on and play the slideshow once it senses a movement. digital photo frames

Runners always need new gear,

Runners always need new gear, and each time we go asics gel into gucci outlet a store, there are new versions of our old favorites. How do apparel companies come up with new products and styles gucci shoes each season? For insights I spoke with Patty Kelly, product manager at the ASICS apparel division. Not only has she been in the business for 20 years, but she has also raced all over the world as a member of the Canadian national triathlon team. Patty is currently working on apparel for fall 2011. Eventually she will asics shoes sale give a designer "product detail," which explains all the specific attributes of a given product she aims to sell. For example, she may request a seven-inch pair of shorts with two pockets and lightweight fabric. The designer will gucci shoulder bags create two or three models, gucci t shirts and she'll pick the one she anticipates the customer will like best. But before that can happen, she must do research, which includes figuring out how to differentiate this season from last and how to stay ahead of emerging trends.

The Cottages at Windermere

The Cottages at Windermere House offer luxury Fractional Ownership of three bedroom cottages on prestigious Lake Rosseau in Muskoka. Fractional ownership at this landmark Muskoka resort provides the benefits of carefree and private cottage ownership in a magnificent resort setting.

Add your comment

CNAS retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <hr><blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Search