Abu Muqawama: Post

Abu Muqawama retains its autonomy and the views and beliefs expressed within the blog do not reflect those of CNAS. Abu Muqawama retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.

Quote of the Day

From Anne Applebaum:

...being right, even morally right, isn't everything. It is also important to be competent, to be consistent, and to be knowledgeable. It's important for your soldiers and diplomats to speak the language of the people you want to influence. It's important to understand the ethnic and tribal divisions of the place you hope to assist. Let's not repeat past mistakes...

To which I would only add that if you are morally justified to intervene but do so incompetently, the incompetence itself amounts to immoral behavior.

Iraq, Libya

23 comments

Here! Here! Or as the

Here! Here! Or as the RainBuffalo says on West Texas Plains, pull your head out of your ass and stop blowing smoke up ours! If you cant roll up your sleeves and help, go away.

"To which I would only add

"To which I would only add that if you are morally justified to intervene but do so incompetently, the incompetence itself amounts to immoral behavior. "

This, is the quote of the day.

"To which I would only add

"To which I would only add that if you are morally justified to intervene but do so incompetently, the incompetence itself amounts to immoral behavior. "

Gibberish.

Ex, Not to get too

Ex,
Not to get too philosophical on you, but incompetence is not, itself, immoral.

I would say that a great power attempting to do something morally right incompetently can be more harmful than a small power doing something immoral ,competently.

@12:33 Visitor It ain't

@12:33 Visitor

It ain't gibberish, its a common concept, akin to what you find in US tort law for instance. Going in as a good samaritan is great and its promoted, but if you don't use due care and make it worse, you'll get punished for it. That's the "in a nutshell explination."

http://definitions.uslegal.com/g/good-samaritans/

Of course I've now opened this thread up to PI attorney rants...

"To which I would only add

"To which I would only add that if you are morally justified to intervene but do so incompetently, the incompetence itself amounts to immoral behavior. "

Allrighty then, we have established that PC COIN is immoral, as pursuing an approach that has proven itself repeatedly and catastrophically ineffective is a clear admission of incompetence. Nice of AM to admit that at last!

No problem here Boondoggle,

No problem here Boondoggle, just tuning a little late.....

Question is does all this tort stuff align with National Interest and Security. Seems we loose all the smart stuff along the way and get stupid. Why else would the US support so many ME dictators?

So we can step on our dictator?

Given our track record of the

Given our track record of the past 4 decades, I would be a hell of lot less concerned about being morally justified to enter a conflict.....but to implement the task in an incompetent manner. I would suggest worrying about the exact opposite.

AM, Come on! Did you not

AM,

Come on! Did you not learn anything from your two favorite people?

http://bhavanajagat.files.wordpress.com/2011/01/president-richard-nixon-...

Boondoggle: Did you actually

Boondoggle: Did you actually read the link you posted?

The purpose of good Samaritan laws is to protect a well meaning helper who fouls up. The laws recognize that in trying to do the moral thing the Samaritan should be protected if his actions have been reasonable. He need not be successful.

"To which I would only add

"To which I would only add that if you are morally justified to intervene but do so incompetently, the incompetence itself amounts to immoral behavior. "

If because of you're moral justification you go in.
You hold yourself at a higher standard.
Simply by the fact that you are morally "right".
And you have to stand up to this standard, be competent.
If you do not... you do not honor the moral edge you had on your enemies, and you can't just rely on this moral edge anymore because you have not taken the means of honoring it.

Incompetence in this case is at least dangerous... if not totally immoral. Would you like a guy to come and try to reanimate you if he doesn't even know how to do it ? He could fuck you up pretty bad and kill you even before first responders arrive to you.

The intention maybe as noble as you want, but skill must never be exchanged for luck.
You have to back that up by doing things right.

On that point I'm entirely in agreement with Andrew.

Do or do not, there is no try said some little green philosopher.

I think the invasion of Iraq

I think the invasion of Iraq can be classified as immoral due to the incompetence with which it was planned and implemented, if not for the fabricated story of WMD and ties to bin Ladin. Thanks Rummy.

@ visitor 7:32 From the

@ visitor 7:32

From the article:
For example, t(h)e following is the Hawaii Good Samaritan Act
"Any person who in good faith renders emergency care, without renumeration or expectation of renumeration, at the scene of an accident or emergency to the victim of the accident or emergency shall not be liable for any civil damages resulting from the persons acts or omission, except for such damages as may result from the persons gross negligence or wanton acts or omissions."

It's not a perfect analogy, I don't think many would argue international law, to such as it exists to govern what this country does in the first place, really promotes interventions (for a bunch of completely good reasons) like good samaritan laws do, but even in the case of good samaritan laws where they DO promote intervention they don't protect the good samaritan if they act like an idiot (my personal legal term for "gross negligence").

Boondoggle: Gross negligence

Boondoggle: Gross negligence and wanton acts are above simple incompetence.

A well meaning person trying to help but failing due to his incompetence isn't acting immorally.

The immorality of an action lies principally in the motives of the actor including indifference to the likely consequences.

The world's most popular

The world's most popular marathon, the ING New York City Marathon?, is just around the corner, and if you are one of the nearly 40,000 individuals taking asics shoes to the streets on that day, the best of luck to you—you're in for an incredible race experience! While the race may be the main gucci outlet event, you should make the most of your time in the asics running shoes Big Apple, especially if you're a first-timer to the city. If you're able to shuffle around the gucci shoulder bags city after the marathon, reward yourself with lots of sightseeing! In terms of food, New York is world-renowned, offering everything from food-cart falafel to the finest in high-society dining. Just walking New York's streets gucci shoes will expose you to a asics gel plethora of enticing smells, so you needn't worry about going hungry. Still, if you have a hankering for something special, it always pays to do your research ahead of time. For a hearty prerace pasta dinner, consider a visit to Little Italy, located in lower Manhattan, or wander over to the West Village, which boasts a number of highly praised Italian restaurants.

The best way to deal with

The best way to deal with different material surfaces is to choose a watch that has been highly polished as that will create a very smooth surface that will draw a lot of compliments regardless of how close it feels to the material used in the actual fake Spazio24 watches that are sold today
We are sure that with our first class after sale service and quick delivery of the watches, you will believer that the Ulysse Nardin watches replica with top quality can also be the superbly desirable creations as the originals
fake Piaget are very hale and hearty and fruitful watches
These fake Ebel watches come with three features of beautiful looks, ethnic modernity and superb activity
If you are willing to achive this image you may start from buying a Rolex SubMariner watches
So you can buy several popular models of Bedat & co fake for the price of just one original watch
A duplicate watch offered by replica Sinn watches will be your wonderful possession
So in the modern time, have you been seeking for the Christian Dior watches replica since these watches are so stunning and fashionable? The Chronoswiss watches replica which I bought is in high quality but at reasonable price
Today replica Bedat & co can reproduce popular watches brands with the utmost precision, it is no wonder that replica Bell & Ross attract most people's attention
thefirstwatches.com offers a wide variety of the top class and excellent quality Breitling watches replica to choose from
You can buy a replica Rolex or any of the Cartier watches as per your choice! Moreover one is assured of money back guarantee in case of dissatisfaction along with warranty
Diesel watches Welcome to shop well made Ebel watches here
replica Oris you may know there are many other useful items from the watch awful, except for the tool

 How many powerhouse stories

 How many powerhouse stories do you read on Sportsline, ESPN or MLB about the Marlins? How many times do you read about the fact that despite the pedigree of the Amazing Braves, the Marlins have not only won 2 more wholesale jerseys championships in the last 10 years, but wholesale hockey jerseys even as recent as last cheap hockey jerseys year, young team and all, were only 1 game behind the BravesOnline trade of clothes has become a rage these days due to several reasons04 ERA wholesale nhl jerseys which resulted in Rivera coming in third in the Cy discount jerseys Young voting that year No it wasn't used to kill someone wholesale football jerseys but instead it was signed for the infamous mayor William Thompson of Chicago, who allegedly had links with the underworld boss 'Al Capone'

 The bottom line is, the Cubs are available to us wholesale jersey every day as MLB's version of the Jerry Springer wholesale nfl jerseys ShowThe first NBA team that has wholesale nba jerseys a snazzy jersey is the Phoenix Suns Tiger Woods is a pro athlete without a team, but on any given day you'll find over 3000 Wholesale mlb jerseys items on eBay related to him, and his personal line of golf apparel, the Tiger Woods Collection, makes Wholesale nhl jerseys hundreds of millions Wholesale nhl jersey every year I've come to realize that wholesale jersey Adidas has the best authentic jerseys

 These can be great for wholesale nba jerseys other outdoor events - fishing, hiking, or tailgatingBaseball is America's favorite past time, at least during the summer months cheap jerseys Mark Cuban, is not worried about dollar, when it comes to winning and examplesShawn Marion and Jason Kidd Both players Wholesale mlb jerseys have achieved numerous milestones in their careers, events that have boosted the sales cheap hockey jerseys of their respective jerseys

 It has become a custom on the part of the spectators to wear such jerseys to sports events where a wholesale nfl jerseys particular team is playing But as piece of advice, it will be better if you one of popular players that may had develop wholesale nba jerseys a good name inside and outside the field before Nearly jersey wholesale every sport jerseys wholesale has a cap to promote their team Ovechkin is one of the cheap nhl jerseys league's most popular players, and currently has the No

 You can find almost wholesale baseball jerseys any item you like bearing the sports, team or player that wholesale mlb jerseys you hockey jerseys cheap specifically like Wholesale nhl jersey in a replica jerseys snap Wholesale nhl jerseys Halladay tossed the 20th perfect game in cheap nhl jerseys MLB history on May 29 and threw the second no-hitter in postseason history, mowing down Cincinnati, for the icing on the cake Today, of course, wholesale baseball jerseys people who love baseball have had wholesale nfl jerseys their illusions shattered with controversy over steroid wholesale jerseys use, home run records, and so many other scandals Over his 22 year career in baseball, Kaline represented consistency and durability to MLB fans everywhere and lit up the night sky wholesale hockey jerseys in Detroit was the Detroit Tigers most enduring star since the legendary Ty Cobb

 

Great report, I ran across an

Great report, I ran across an awful lot today. The political arena is very much unraveling fast. Worldwide executives need to take a grave look at policy conflicts. Excellent information. fix credit | online surveys for money

Twenty- karen millen dresses

Twenty- karen millen dresses is moving fast and long-term friends and partners of the Trent and Kyle Thomas Stein, as they met in Columbus, to finalize the details of their second season of their Karen Millen sale line Black Hat Both take a passion for art in many forms, have decided to make a mutual discount karen millen. Trent and Kyle decided to express their artistic visions through the images and graphics. And 'in the blood to push the envelope in themselves and what they are involved in After the creation of logos for local musicians , event flyers and skate and Karen Millen dress, and collaborate with other local brands, have decided to overcome their passion for art and fashion, and to start their own brand of Black Hat.Ranger Karen Millen outlet are often worn to ward off attacks paintball. Hiding behind "enemy" is part of a paintball game. To be a secret, hidden from them, which is expected to play with paintballs is a lot of fun.With Karen Millen dresses on sale like this, not only hidden, but when you get down low so that you can not see, you will be able not to the knees. Military clothing will make you popular in a game of paintball, because you'll be more prepared and ready to rumble. Ultra Force Ranger camouflage is made of polyester / cotton with eight hook front and zippered pockets for you to do a lot of extra ammo.

feiduting We are the best

feiduting
We are the best soccer jersey supplier, all the soccer jerseys on jerseybbs.com are REPLICA SOCCER JERSEYS, but their quality are good, because many soccer jersey shopping websites are selling our discount soccer jerseys, espcially the thailand quality cheap soccer jerseys, They are the same as the official jerseys

According to a figure that most of the luxury brands consumer in China range frome 2os to 30s.
wholesale polo shirts are all young Women's love, wearing the designers will attract passerby glance, it make them be in good mood all the day.

With the increase in printing needs all over the world, manufacturers of Ink Cartridges are hard pressed to meet the ever-increasing demand. Consumer satisfaction ranks highest in the quest to fulfill company priorities. Buying printers is relatively cheap nowadays, but unfortunately, the Ecco Key West Mens same thing cannot be said about the CISS or cartridges that require to be replaced often.

feiduting BrandDream, Top

feiduting
BrandDream, Top designer apparel supplier, FREE SHIPPING(for orders of 10pcs to US, UK, CA and AU), louboutin shoes, Cheap Ralph Lauren polo shirts, Cheap Ed Hardy Wholesale, juicy couture tracksuits, Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes, Discount Sheepskin Boots, Wholesale Abercrombie, Christian Audigier Clothing and Shopping
wholesale designer clothing, accept Credit Card and PayPal, Quality Guarantee, Good Discounts and Trusty Business.

Do you know the different between the replica and fake watch? In fact the replica watches is made from the similar material and parts with the orginal one,the more important it is legal, however the fake is illegal.

A wide range of high quality and excellent perfermance wholesale Jerseys, wholesale nike shox, Cheap Nike airmax Shoes wholesale and Cheap Nike airmax Shoes in our shop welcome your visit.wholesale Jerseys, wholesale nike shox, Cheap Nike airmax Shoes, Cheap Nike airmax Shoes wholesale.

cheap soccer jerseys,replica soccer jerseys are very high sales volume, and many people liked to buy it replica soccer jerseyscheap soccer jerseys.

Add your comment

CNAS retains the right to delete comments that include words that incite violence; are predatory, hateful, or intended to intimidate or harass; or degrade people on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or disability. In summary, don't be a jerk.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <hr><blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Search