December 16, 2025
Can the Global Order Be Saved? Not Without Punishing Russia
This article was originally published in INKSTICK.
In recent weeks, the United States has spearheaded a new flurry of diplomacy aimed at reaching a settlement to the Russia-Ukraine war. While it remains unclear whether a peace agreement will materialize, it has become more and more evident that Washington is willing to sell out Kyiv at any cost to get a deal done quickly — even as Russian President Vladimir Putin jeopardizes the global order.
Rushing to strike a quick deal is a critical mistake. With Moscow refusing to entertain a deal on anything other than its own terms, the conditions for reaching a just settlement remain absent. Forcing Kyiv into a lopsided agreement would not only suppress its future sovereignty — it would imperil the broader principles underpinning global order.
The only way to succeed in the urgent task of achieving a just peace settlement is radically reshaping Russia’s calculus.
Since World War II, the norm against territorial conquest — enshrined as international law in the 1945 United Nations Charter — has become remarkably widespread. While interstate war has not disappeared, it has declined dramatically, as its legitimacy as a tool of dispute resolution has evaporated. Evidence of this norm is visible in the language Vladimir Putin uses to camouflage Russia’s war of aggression as a “special military operation” taken in alleged self-defense.
Yet the prohibition on force is in grave danger. Russia has yet to be truly punished for its aggression. Meanwhile, unilateral military action and threats of such action have proliferated globally, coming from countries including the United States, Israel, and more. Perhaps assessing that the trend is in Russia’s favor, the Kremlin has even abandoned its rhetorical cover for the invasion, becoming emboldened enough to openly call it a “war.”
Read the full article in INKSTICK.
More from CNAS
-
Reflecting on Four Years of War in Ukraine
Podcast
This week marks the four-year anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Brussels Sprouts wanted to mark this somber milestone with a look at the conflict and the...
By Andrea Kendall-Taylor & Jim Townsend
-
Can China Capitalize on Changing Transatlantic Currents?
Podcast
This week’s episode of Brussels Sprouts picks up in the aftermath of the Munich Security Conference. The U.S. tone at Munich was notably more conciliatory than last year, as U...
By Andrea Kendall-Taylor & Jim Townsend
-
The Sound of Munich: Autonomy, Anxiety, and the Twilight of Transatlantic Order
Commentary
This article was originally published in War on the Rocks. Munich was warmer than Washington this weekend, both in weather and in sentiment. Neither development was widely fo...
By Richard Fontaine
-
Commentary
Transatlantic Security / Middle East Security
Migration Can Provide the Manpower for European DefenseThis article was originally published in Foreign Policy. Europe faces parallel challenges that policymakers have yet to connect: a pressing military recruitment shortage and a...
By Adham Sahloul
