May 28, 2026
The Coming Crisis of NATO Deterrence
This article was originally published in Foreign Affairs.
President Donald Trump is making a dangerous bet in Europe. This month, the United States announced that it was canceling the deployment of a long-range precision strike battalion to Germany and withdrawing some 5,000 troops from the country. It also abruptly canceled a rotational 4,000-to-5,000-strong combat team bound for Poland, following the earlier cancellation of a similar deployment to Romania in 2025. (The White House has suggested that new forces may still go to Poland but has not specified whether those would come from the United States or be redirected from Germany.) This week, European allies have told media that the Pentagon has informed NATO that it will shrink the forces Washington would rapidly deploy to Europe in a crisis—that is, in the event of a Russian attack on alliance territory.
If Washington signals an unwillingness to engage in conventional military action to defend Europe, Putin will conclude that Russia has escalation dominance on the continent and may climb the conventional rungs. That would leave the American president with a stark choice: concede Russian gains or leap to the nuclear rung.
At the same time, the Trump administration has sought to reassure allies that its commitment to Europe’s defense remains undiminished, pledging to sustain the nuclear umbrella over NATO. This seemingly tidy solution to burden sharing—fewer boots on the ground, an ultimate backstop—may appeal to some American voters, but it is strategically dangerous, eroding the foundations of the deterrence that has protected the transatlantic alliance for decades.
Read the full article in Foreign Affairs.
More from CNAS
-
Defense / Transatlantic Security
Ukraine Peace Push Turns to NATO and DonbasBloomberg Economics defense lead Becca Wasser tells Bloomberg This Weekend that a U.S. proposal linking NATO membership to Ukrainian concessions in the Donbas represents movem...
By Becca Wasser
-
Examining Kushner’s European Security Framework
This week, American, Ukrainian, and Russian officials are gathering in Abu Dhabi for the first trilateral peace talks in nine months. But the negotiations could have implicati...
By Andrea Kendall-Taylor & Jim Townsend
-
Defense / Indo-Pacific Security / Transatlantic Security / Middle East Security / Energy, Economics & Security
CNAS Insights | National Security Agenda in the New Congress: A 10-Item To-Do ListWhen Democratic majorities sweep into Congress in January, Washington will return to divided government. The prospect of stalemate will be real, with Democrats prone to opposi...
By Richard Fontaine
-
A Blue Wave in America: The Midterms and Foreign Policy
In a stunning midterm election, Democrats have won back control of the House and Senate. Even with some races still uncalled, Democrats have secured at least 54 Senate seats a...
By Andrea Kendall-Taylor & Jim Townsend
