March 11, 2026
The Curse of Middle-Sized Wars
This article was originally published in Foreign Affairs.
In 1988, the military historian James Stokesbury observed that democracies are best at fighting either little wars, which are reserved for “professionals” and don’t involve ordinary citizens, or really big wars that mobilize all of society. Those democracies, he continued, have “very real problems trying to fight a middle-sized war, where some go and some stay home.”
The United States exists in the world as a de facto empire, and misbegotten wars are embedded in the history of imperialism itself.
It may be uncomfortable to consider the so-called forever warsin the Middle East—which have killed or wounded tens of thousands of U.S. soldiers and left countless dead on all sides—as merely middle-sized. But Stokesbury’s point is one of comparison. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as those in Korea and Vietnam, as gruesome as they were, cannot be equated to the two big world wars of the twentieth century. Nor can they be grouped with little wars, such as the invasion of Grenada in 1983 and of Panama in 1989, which made headlines for a few days but were essentially imperial policing actions. U.S. military interventions in Bosnia in 1995 and Kosovo in 1999 also had exceedingly few American casualties and were mainly air operations conducted within strict limits.
Read the full article in Foreign Affairs.
More from CNAS
-
Defense / Indo-Pacific Security / Transatlantic Security / Middle East Security / Energy, Economics & Security
CNAS Insights | National Security Agenda in the New Congress: A 10-Item To-Do ListWhen Democratic majorities sweep into Congress in January, Washington will return to divided government. The prospect of stalemate will be real, with Democrats prone to opposi...
By Richard Fontaine
-
Indo-Pacific Security / Transatlantic Security / Middle East Security
The Axis of Upheaval Goes to WarThey are fine-tuning their cooperation to make their partners more resilient—and more dangerous to the United States—while limiting costs and risks....
By Andrea Kendall-Taylor & Richard Fontaine
-
U.S. Troops Are Leaving Iraq. What Does That Mean for U.S. Influence in the Region?
Hamzeh Hadad, an adjunct fellow at the Center for a New American Security, joins NPR's Consider This to discuss U.S. forces withdrawing from Iraq after a two-decade-long milit...
By Hamzeh Hadad
-
Rational Security: The “All Takin’ and No Givin’” Edition
Alex Zerden, adjunct senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security, joins the Rational Security podcast to discuss the week's biggest news in national security, incl...
By Alex Zerden
