March 11, 2026
The Curse of Middle-Sized Wars
This article was originally published in Foreign Affairs.
In 1988, the military historian James Stokesbury observed that democracies are best at fighting either little wars, which are reserved for “professionals” and don’t involve ordinary citizens, or really big wars that mobilize all of society. Those democracies, he continued, have “very real problems trying to fight a middle-sized war, where some go and some stay home.”
The United States exists in the world as a de facto empire, and misbegotten wars are embedded in the history of imperialism itself.
It may be uncomfortable to consider the so-called forever warsin the Middle East—which have killed or wounded tens of thousands of U.S. soldiers and left countless dead on all sides—as merely middle-sized. But Stokesbury’s point is one of comparison. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as those in Korea and Vietnam, as gruesome as they were, cannot be equated to the two big world wars of the twentieth century. Nor can they be grouped with little wars, such as the invasion of Grenada in 1983 and of Panama in 1989, which made headlines for a few days but were essentially imperial policing actions. U.S. military interventions in Bosnia in 1995 and Kosovo in 1999 also had exceedingly few American casualties and were mainly air operations conducted within strict limits.
Read the full article in Foreign Affairs.
More from CNAS
-
Podcast
Indo-Pacific Security / Middle East Security
The Global Power Shift No One Is Talking About – And Who’s Driving ItMost people see the world as the U.S. vs. China. But the real power shift is happening elsewhere. Richard Fontaine, CEO of the Center for a New American Security and a former ...
By Richard Fontaine
-
Podcast
Indo-Pacific Security / Middle East Security
Why Trump’s Efforts to Force Iran to Concede to U.S. Demands Aren’t Working"So far, there has been no combination of carrots and sticks that has brought Iran to the terms that the Americans want. And if the idea is that, at some point soon, Iran will...
By Richard Fontaine
-
With War on Its Doorstep, Iraq Taps a Political Outsider to Become Prime Minister
Podcast
After a long political impasse, Ali al-Zaidi has been tapped to become Iraq’s new prime minister. A wealthy oligarch, al-Zaidi is seen as both a compromise candidate, but also...
By Hamzeh Hadad
-
The Russia-Iran Partnership
Commentary
The United States needs to prioritize increasing the cost of Russia’s support for Iran; sanctions alone are not sufficient and often encourage U.S. adversaries to get more inv...
By Delaney Soliday
