March 15, 2022

A New Nuclear Deal With Iran Shouldn’t Be Accompanied By Terrorist Legitimization

Iran has a new demand for U.S. diplomats as they conclude what will hopefully be the final round of negotiations for a new nuclear agreement later this month: Remove the 2019 U.S. foreign terrorist organization (FTO) designation on Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard (IRGC). The United States should reject this demand, even if it risks Iranian noncompliance with negotiations. Removing the terrorist stigma from the IRGC will embolden Iranian proxies and anger regional allies.

Removing the label of terrorism should take effort on behalf of the offending party, something the Islamic Republic is unwilling to provide.

FTO designations can be assigned to groups if they meet three criteria under U.S. Code §1189—the group must be foreign, engaged in terrorist activity, and threaten U.S. national security. By labeling a group as an FTO, the United States creates extraterritorial criminal and civil liability for parties engaged in providing them with material support. There are currently 73 groups listed, and their status is reviewed every five years by the U.S. State Department.

Maintaining the FTO designation applies political pressure on states that interact with the IRGC—namely Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon—to significantly alter their relationships or risk international pariah status. The Iranian marketplace becomes dangerous for prospective business partners, as any dealings with the country could be perceived as IRGC financing since it is state-sponsored. Designations also clarify U.S. attitudes toward international actors and let Iran know that the actions of its paramilitary organization are not tolerated by the United States, irrespective of any future diplomatic re-engagement.

Read the full article from Global Security Review.

  • Video
    • February 1, 2024
    What Comes Next for the U.S. in the Middle East

    Following a fatal attack on U.S. troops in Jordan, Jonathan Lord analyzes what comes next for the U.S. Watch the full interview with NBC News....

    By Jonathan Lord

  • Commentary
    • The Hill
    • July 19, 2023
    Biden Needs to Deal with China’s Ever-Closer Ties to Iran

    Iran and China’s growing relationship is no longer a “what-if,” but a “what-do-we-do-now.”...

    By Arona Baigal & Kiana Alirezaie

  • Video
    • June 1, 2023
    Why U.S.-Iran Tensions Are On The Rise In The Persian Gulf

    Over the last decade, Iran has been causing more and more headaches for oil tanker operators in the Strait of Hormuz, a central artery of global trade. In the last two years a...

    By Arona Baigal

  • Reports
    • March 29, 2023
    Disarming the Bomb

    Negotiations to return to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), known commonly as the Iran nuclear deal, reached an impasse this past year. Further, Iran made parall...

    By Jonathan Lord, Arona Baigal, Hunter Streling & LCDR Stewart Latwin

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia