November 27, 2018

Against the Great Powers: Reflections on Balancing Nuclear and Conventional Power

By Elbridge Colby

The fundamental problem facing U.S. national security — and indeed grand — strategy is clear: The United States seeks to extend deterrence to dozens of allies in parts of the world that are increasingly shadowed by Russia and China, each of which fields survivable nuclear arsenals and conventional forces that are more and more formidable in their respective regions. An increasingly powerful China seeks ascendancy in Asia and ultimately beyond, while Russia has recovered some of its military potency and aspires to upend or at least substantially revise the post-Cold War European settlement. Both China and Russia have developed strategies and forces designed to enable them to attack or suborn U.S. allies or partners and make such an effort potentially worth the risks and costs. Their aspirations place them at odds — or at least in tension — with U.S. interests in defending its alliance architecture, and their increased capability to pursue these aspirations makes them more dangerous and the possibility of war with them more likely.

In the face of these challenges, Washington wants to deter and, if necessary, defeat attacks on its allies by Russia or China. The problem is that these alliances are, while of course important, still fundamentally secondary interests for the United States. Yet Washington wisely seeks to defend them from states that have the assured ability to conduct nuclear strikes on the American homeland, which, naturally, represents the profoundest type of peril to the nation’s ultimate primary interest: its survival as a functioning society.

Read the full article in Texas National Security Review.

  • Commentary
    • June 2, 2021
    Sharper: Defense Tech

    The prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI) systems, the growing centrality of information warfare, and threats to traditional command and control are redefining combat in ...

    By Jennie Matuschak, Ainikki Riikonen & Anna Pederson

  • Video
    • May 24, 2021
    United States can improve deterrence by posing dilemmas to China and Russia

    Chris Dougherty, Senior Fellow at the Center for a New American Security, joins Government Matters to discuss strategy for multi-domain information warfare. Watch the full in...

    By Chris Dougherty

  • Commentary
    • C4ISRNET
    • May 20, 2021
    The Pentagon needs a plan to get punched in the mouth

    The Pentagon should aim for degradation dominance: operating effectively enough with degraded systems. Put simply, the Pentagon needs a plan for getting punched in the mouth....

    By Chris Dougherty

  • Reports
    • May 20, 2021
    More than Half the Battle

    The DoD needs to embrace, rather than fight against, the changes in the character of warfare and learn to thrive within its chaos in ways that China and Russia may be unable t...

    By Chris Dougherty

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia