December 02, 2019
The Many Questions Trump’s Pardons Raise About Civil-Military Relations
When President Donald Trump granted pardons to two Army officers—one convicted of war crimes, the other accused of them—and reversed the demotion of a Navy SEAL who was convicted of posing with the corpse of an enemy combatant, he exposed several troubling ambiguities about civilian-military relations in the United States. Civilian and uniformed defense officials feel most at ease when the dynamics of their relationship are clear-cut, with formal and tacit assignments of roles and responsibilities that leave little room for uncertainty. In practice, though, things are rarely so black and white.
There is only one certainty so far in the drama unfolding over the pardons: that Trump, as commander-in-chief, can legally order the Navy to cease an administrative review and allow Eddie Gallagher to remain a Navy SEAL. The many other questions of civilian control raised by this incident are gray areas.
Read the full article in World Politics Review.
More from CNAS
-
Sharper: Global Coronavirus Response
Commentary
Analysis from CNAS experts on the most critical challenges in U.S. foreign policy....
By Chris Estep & Cole Stevens
-
Want to Recruit Women? Address Sexual Assault and Harassment
Commentary
Civilian leadership and Congress must demand more than regular accounting and comprehensive training....
By Emma Moore
-
Adapting the Image and Culture of Special Operations Forces
Commentary
It is the people in special operations who ultimately make the difference between mission success and failure....
By Emma Moore & Lt Col Stewart J. Parker
-
The Pandemic and the Protests: Necessity and Perception of the National Guard
Commentary
COVID-19 has demonstrated the flexibility and dedication of guardsmen and the necessity of adequate funding....
By Nathalie Grogan
