April 20, 2017

The Mysterious Case of the Wayward Aircraft Carrier

There is a sobering reality beyond this week’s strange “Where’s Waldo?” story of the USS Carl Vinson and its strike group: For a period of time, significant confusion existed as to the location of a U.S. aircraft carrier strike group, one of the most potent weapons in the American arsenal, at a moment of high tension on the Korean Peninsula.

Although not (yet) a major crisis, this incident portends deep problems with the White House, its chain of command, and its approach to national security. At best, The Vinson episode suggests policy gaps between the president and his top military advisers over how to act toward North Korea. Worse, it appears the president has not firmly established control over the chain of command—or that he possibly overdelegated authority to his generals and admirals. Further, this incident sends deeply disturbing signals to allies and adversaries regarding the president’s control over the military and the credibility of his statements, diluting the deterrent value of American words and actions.

Let’s start with two fundamental premises of U.S. civil-military relations. First, the president is the elected commander in chief of the military; short of declaring war, he has the power to order military deployments and operations, and be held politically accountable for them. Second, the president ought to know with accuracy the locations and readiness of major U.S. military assets, and have the ability to command those forces as needed to protect the country.

Read the full article at Slate.

  • Podcast
    • February 11, 2025
    Hegseth Says Trump Boosted Military Recruiting. It’s Been Improving for over a Year

    Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says military recruiting has shot up since the Trump administration's return. In fact, it's been improving for at least a year, with big jumps i...

    By Taren Sylvester

  • Podcast
    • February 4, 2025
    How Long Will Deterrence Hold?

    Mike hosts Michèle Flournoy, former Co-Founder and Chief Executive Officer of the Center for a New American Security (CNAS), where she currently serves as Chair of the Board o...

    By Michèle Flournoy

  • Podcast
    • January 30, 2025
    Colombia Tariffs, Banning Chinese Drones, and Stacie Pettyjohn on Drone Warfare

    Emily and Geoff play a quick round of Tariff Tarot to dissect Trump’s tariff threats on Colombia last weekend. Then they dig in to the bipartisan debate over banning various c...

    By Emily Kilcrease, Stacie Pettyjohn & Geoffrey Gertz

  • Commentary
    • Foreign Policy
    • January 24, 2025
    Don’t Talk About the War

    Confronting aggressors and getting them to the negotiation table requires both carrots and sticks—in other words, diplomacy and military power....

    By Franz-Stefan Gady

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia