September 25, 2017

The Problem with 'the Best of Intentions' Foreign Policy

By Robert D. Kaplan

The nineteenth-century Germans focused so much on philosophy partly in order not to compete with the protean genius of Goethe, who had dominated all the other literary genres in Germany for so long. And so we have Hegel, Nietzsche and Schopenhauer defining, among other things, the concept of tragedy. But it is Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel who concerns me here, because he formulated some concepts apt to our foreign policy debates regarding armed intervention, particularly in the Middle East.

Hegel notes that one example of a tragic situation is when a family duty is in conflict with a wider social or universal duty: a foreign policy parallel to this could be when the interests of state are in conflict with the wider interests of humanity—with both points of view more or less justified. Edith Hamilton, the mid-twentieth-century American classicist, interpreting Hegel, says “the only tragic subject is a spiritual subject in which each side has a claim on our sympathy.” Another earlier interpreter of Hegel, the English literary scholar A. C. Bradley, said that tragedy “appeals to the spirit” because “it is itself a conflict of the spirit.”

Read the full op-ed in The National Interest.

  • Commentary
    • Real Clear World
    • February 24, 2021
    Venezuela's Story: Democratic Paths to Authoritarianism

    Venezuelan presidents Hugo Chávez and Nicolás Maduro have twisted democracy to achieve authoritarian ends....

    By Katie Galgano

    • Commentary
    • The Wall Street Journal
    • August 24, 2016
    Australia’s Ambivalence Makes It Vulnerable

    With Washington’s rising focus on Asia, America’s close and longstanding alliance with Australia has taken on new significance. Australia today is boosting its military streng...

    By Richard Fontaine

    • Commentary
    • The Diplomat
    • July 27, 2016
    A Thaw in the US-New Zealand Nuclear Freeze

    The visit of a U.S. Navy warship to New Zealand in November will mark the close of a 30 year period of security estrangement between two democratic nations. Announced during V...

    By Richard Fontaine

    • Commentary
    • The Wall Street Journal
    • June 30, 2016
    How to Crash Putin’s Brexit Party

    For decades, NATO and the European Union have silently worked in unison. The former required a foundation of European unity, and the EU to a significant extent provided that, ...

    By Robert D. Kaplan

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia