September 02, 2022

Don’t Believe the Generals

A T-shirt that was popular with veterans for much of America’s nearly 20-year war in Afghanistan showed a helicopter in flight with the caption "We were winning when I left." U.S. generals seem to be the only ones who didn’t get the joke. On the first anniversary of our botched withdrawal, the military leaders most responsible for America’s disastrous outcome in Afghanistan have continued to loudly insist that the war was winnable when they were in charge, and that responsibility for the debacle must lie with someone else.

The outcome of America’s commitment was an Afghan government and military that couldn’t hold out long enough even for U.S. forces to leave with a semblance of dignity.

Retired Generals Frank McKenzie and Joseph Votel, the last two commanders of U.S. Central Command, which includes Afghanistan, recently made the case that America should have stayed indefinitely, arguing that the pullout was a mistake and that America could have defended its interests—and kept the Taliban at bay—with a small residual force of a few thousand soldiers. And in The Atlantic, the retired general and former CIA director David Petraeus, who commanded the war in Afghanistan after presiding over the surge that helped bring temporary stability to Iraq, wrote that more than a decade ago “we had finally established the right big ideas and overarching strategy.” But the problem, he maintained, was that America did not have the stomach for a “sustained, generational commitment.”

Read the full article from The Atlantic.

  • Commentary
    • Military Times
    • November 22, 2023
    The Pentagon’s New Opportunity to Boost Readiness among Female Troops

    First lady Jill Biden on Nov. 13 announced the launch of the White House Initiative on Women’s Health Research to highlight the goal of fundamentally changing the way women’s ...

    By Katherine L. Kuzminski

  • Commentary
    • Sharper
    • November 8, 2023
    Sharper: Serving America's Veterans

    As America’s military continues to struggle to meet recruiting targets, the proper treatment of veterans and servicemembers is increasingly vital to ensure the All-Volunteer F...

    By Anna Pederson & Andrew Spafford

  • Commentary
    • Sharper
    • September 6, 2023
    Sharper: National Security Workforce

    A capable workforce is central to the effectiveness of any government, military, or industry. Opaque processes and standards that lag behind the private sector contribute to r...

    By Anna Pederson, Taren Sylvester & Charles Horn

  • Podcast
    • August 29, 2023
    Here's one prescription for getting more qualified civilians into national security work

    As threats to the United States multiply, the government will need growing numbers of capable civilians in national security. But creaky apparatus for hiring and clearing peop...

    By Katherine L. Kuzminski

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia