June 16, 2022

Strange Debacle: Misadventures In Assessing Russian Military Power

By Chris Dougherty

The article was originally published by War on the Rocks.

Russia’s botched invasion of Ukraine has befuddled most defense analysts and Russia experts. They expected Russia’s larger and better-equipped forces would quickly dispatch Ukraine’s military and force its government to surrender. Instead, Ukrainian resilience has bested Russian incompetence, creating an initial Ukrainian upset that has now settled into brutal, attritional combat in the Donbas. After over 100 days of the most intense combat Europe has seen in decades, the outcome remains very much in doubt.

I recently appeared on an episode of the War on the Rocks podcast along with two Russia experts — Michael Kofman and Dara Massicot — and military historian Gian Gentile to discuss how analysts misjudged Russia’s armed forces and their invasion of Ukraine. Several themes emerged from the discussion, including the difficulty of predicting combat performance, the corruption and “gun-decking” (falsification of reports) within the Russian armed forces, and the lunacy of the initial Russian war plan, which didn’t reflect their military strategy, doctrine, exercises, or past operations, or even basic military principles like having a single commander.

Russia’s botched invasion of Ukraine has befuddled most defense analysts and Russia experts.

Others have taken a more critical approach. The historian Philipps Payson O’Brien, for example, wrote an article for The Atlantic early in the war comparing the Western failure to grasp Russian weakness to misguided assessments of French vulnerabilities prior to its defeat by Germany in 1940. He argued that Western analysts overlooked Russian weakness because they fixated on weapons systems and doctrine and ignored key factors like logistics, leadership, and morale. O’Brien is a serious thinker whose arguments merit engagement. He raises important questions about how analysts and policymakers assess military power. Yet he makes key errors and misjudges defense analysis and the Russian military experts.

Read the full article from War on the Rocks.

  • Commentary
    • September 28, 2022
    Sharper: NATO

    As the war in Ukraine pushes past the six-month mark, NATO stands at a critical juncture. In the face of renewed great-power competition in Europe, the alliance has proved to ...

    By Anna Pederson & Michael Angeloni

  • Commentary
    • Project Syndicate
    • September 26, 2022
    Russia, Iran, and the Perils of Post-autocracy

    Neither the Russian nor the Iranian regime is now specifically threatened. Each could hang on for years. But this month provided a glimpse of their eventual demise....

    By Robert D. Kaplan

  • Podcast
    • September 23, 2022
    Why Russia Is Losing the War in Ukraine

    Andrea Kendall-Taylor, Director of the Transatlantic Security program at the Center for a New American Security, joins The Ezra Klein Show to discuss how and why in recent wee...

    By Andrea Kendall-Taylor

  • Podcast
    • September 21, 2022
    New Phase of War: Ukrainian Offensive and Russian Mobilization, with Mick Ryan and Rob Lee

    How have recent Ukrainian counteroffensives changed the trajectory of the war? Will Putin’s announcement of Russian mobilization increase the risk of potential escalation? Aft...

    By Andrea Kendall-Taylor, Jim Townsend, Mick Ryan & Rob Lee

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia