August 25, 2021
The Right Way to Structure Cyber Diplomacy
The modern State Department was forged in an era of global transformation. In the 1930s, the department had fewer than 2,000 personnel and, as one historian emphasized, it was a “placid” place that was comfortable with “lethargic diplomacy.” World War II revolutionized the department, which readily transformed itself to handle the demands of planning a new international order. Between 1940 and 1945, the department’s domestic staff levels tripled and its budget doubled.
Today, the State Department is once again confronting the challenge of how to organize itself to cope with new international challenges — not those of wartime, but ones created by rapid technological change. There are ongoing conversations about how the department should handle cyberspace policy, as well as concerns about emerging technologies like artificial intelligence, quantum computing, next generation telecommunications, hypersonics, biotechnology, space capabilities, autonomous vehicles, and many others.
The State Department is once again confronting the challenge of how to organize itself to cope with new international challenges — not those of wartime, but ones created by rapid technological change.
As Ferial Ara Saeed recently emphasized, the department is not structured in a way that makes sense for addressing these matters. She is not alone in having this view, and others have also offered ideas for reform. Former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s proposal for a Bureau of Cyberspace Security and Emerging Technologies focused too narrowly on security, as Saeed correctly diagnoses. As an alternative, she proposes consolidating all technology policy issues under a new under secretary, who would report to the deputy secretary of state for management and resources.
The State Department should be restructured so that it can conduct effective cyber diplomacy, but establishing one bureau for all things technology-related is not the way to proceed. Conceptually, the core challenges for cyberspace policy are different from those related to emerging technology issues, and creating one all-encompassing bureau would generate multiple practical problems. Instead, the department should establish a Bureau of International Cyberspace Policy, as proposed in the Cyber Diplomacy Act. Consolidating cyberspace policy issues in a single bureau would provide greater coherence to overarching priorities and day-to-day diplomatic activities. Emerging technology issues should remain the responsibility of the appropriate existing bureaus.
Read the full article from War on the Rocks.
More from CNAS
-
Technology & National Security
Jensen Huang's Exit: What It Means For Nvidia And America's AI SecurityWhat does Jensen Huang's exit mean for Nvidia, and could the controversy have wider implications for America's AI leadership and national security? Speaking to NDTV, Vivek Chi...
By Vivek Chilukuri
-
Energy, Economics & Security / Technology & National Security
CNAS Insights | The Nvidia Scandal Is a Wake-Up Call for CongressNvidia founder and CEO Jensen Huang has resigned amid revelations of extramarital affairs, including with an alleged Chinese spy. The suspected Chinese asset, Alice Huang, has...
By Emily Kilcrease & Vivek Chilukuri
-
Technology & National Security
Jensen Huang latest: Scandal-hit Nvidia founder asked to testify to Senate - as details of Trump call emergeJensen Huang's resignation was "inevitable" following the affair allegations and while it will be hard for Nvidia in the short term, they still have the best chips in the worl...
By Vivek Chilukuri
-
Technology & National Security
China’s AI Diplomacy Is WorkingIf the United States wants to maintain its lead and make meaningful progress on safety, it needs to treat the dialogue as part of the competition with China....
By Daniel Remler
