Image credit: NASA/Reid Wiseman

June 13, 2023

Why Norms Matter More Than Ever for Space Deterrence and Defense

By Robin Dickey

This article was originally published in War on the Rocks.

Diplomacy and defense have always gone hand-in-hand, and space is no exception. Space has become a fundamental part of daily life and of U.S. national security, ranging from command and control to intelligence and navigation. As the uses of space grow in significance, so too has the question of how to keep space systems safe and secure, and one of the potential answers to that question is to fill in gaps in norms of responsible behavior for space. What may seem like a relatively niche topic actually supports a broad swath of U.S. strategic objectives and has become a central line of effort in protecting national security interests in the space domain. America’s space norm efforts have moved beyond broad public statements and into national defense policies and strategies.

Norms, when done right, can be helpful for defense and deterrence, but it still takes effort and cooperation to strike the right balance.

In response, some commentators have questioned the value of space norms for defense and deterrence. After all, a norm cannot prevent a determined adversary from taking aggressive actions, nor can it intercept a missile or shield a satellite from attack. Criticisms include allegations that nonbinding norms are relatively toothless, that they can unnecessarily constrain U.S. behavior, or that bad actors will simply ignore norms and do what they want anyway. There is some validity in each of these critiques. Yet, norms do play a crucial role in space security, as they have in other domains for centuries.

Read the full article from War on the Rocks.

  • Commentary
    • Foreign Policy
    • September 14, 2023
    Why There Are No Game-Changing Weapons for Ukraine

    Germany has become the second-biggest contributor of military aid to Ukraine after the United States, but you wouldn’t know it by following the debate in Berlin. In a replay o...

    By Franz-Stefan Gady

  • Commentary
    • The Messenger
    • September 13, 2023
    To Avoid AI Catastrophes, We Must Think Smaller

    These incidents are not theoretical, nor are they projections of long-term dangers; rather, these AI tools are already presenting tangible threats to individual health and wel...

    By Josh Wallin

  • Commentary
    • Breaking Defense
    • September 7, 2023
    For Replicator to Work, the Pentagon Needs to Directly Help with Production

    Today’s innovation ecosystem alone cannot achieve the necessary production scale, especially for the less commercially viable classes of systems relevant in the Indo-Pacific....

    By Andrew Metrick

  • Commentary
    • Sharper
    • August 23, 2023
    Sharper: Campaigning and the National Defense Strategy

    The United States faces the unprecedented challenge of simultaneously deterring large-scale conventional aggression by two nuclear-armed powers while also managing other threa...

    By Philip Sheers, Molly Campbell & Anna Pederson

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia