March 12, 2019

Take India’s Side, America

By Elbridge Colby

The moment of maximum danger in the latest India-Pakistan conflict appears to have passed. But after a major attack by Pakistani militants on an Indian military base in Kashmir and the first Indian air strike on Pakistan proper since 1971, tensions are still smoldering between the two South Asian nuclear powers. The episode highlights the need for the U.S. to reassess its role in this volatile part of the world—and to come down firmly on India’s side.

Traditionally Washington has attempted to be a “neutral arbiter” between India and Pakistan. But neutrality may have made the problem worse rather than better. In 1999 Washington intervened to defuse the Kargil crisis. In 2001 and again in 2008, Washington leaned heavily on New Delhi not to respond more forcefully to attacks launched from Pakistani territory. This time, though, the Trump administration appeared reluctant to play referee. Washington should lock in this approach and make clear why.

Washington’s traditional neutrality has created a moral hazard for Pakistan. Islamabad could be confident that its threat of nuclear escalation, even if it didn’t intimidate New Delhi, would enlist American help in tamping down any Indian response. With this insurance policy in place, Pakistan sponsored terrorist attacks within India—in New Delhi in 2001, in Mumbai in 2008, and most recently in Indian Kashmir.

Read the full article in The Wall Street Journal.

  • Commentary
    • The National Interest
    • May 29, 2019
    Modi's Victory Is America’s Opportunity

    History’s largest election has swept Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party back to power in India. More than six-hundred-million Indian voters cast ballots that decisively ga...

    By Richard Fontaine

  • Commentary
    • Global Security Review
    • March 27, 2019
    Two Ways for the United States to Deepen Diplomatic Engagement with ASEAN

    The time has come to demonstrate again that the United States seeks to engage partners in Southeast Asia at the highest levels of government. As the region’s economic and secu...

    By Chris Estep

  • Reports
    • March 20, 2019
    Contested Spaces

    As the competition between the United States and China to shape the course of the 21st century intensifies, Southeast Asia has become a contested space....

    By Patrick M. Cronin, Abigail Grace, Daniel Kliman & Kristine Lee

  • Commentary
    • World Politics Review
    • March 7, 2019
    The Latest India-Pakistan Standoff Raises the Stakes for Future Crises

    It is far from the first flare-up between India and Pakistan in recent years along the Line of Control, the de facto border in the disputed territory of Jammu and Kashmir. But...

    By Kristine Lee & Ben Lamont

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia