July 18, 2026
The Modern Mythology of AI
This article was originally published in Quillette.
In his wonderful new book The Reverse Centaur’s Guide to Life After AI, Cory Doctorow tells us that the most important fact about a technology isn’t what it does, it’s who it does it for, and who it does it to. For veterans, and later for the country, Blue Button was a blow-out win; it helps millions of people manage their care, and it harms nobody.
LLMs can’t replace people, and AI can’t replicate actual thought. But if employers reject these truths and succumb to empty promises and motivated thinking, employees will suffer the immediate, material consequences of being replaced by a tool that cannot actually do their job because their bosses are confused by the perception and temptation of the uncaptured profit margin.
Today, of course, screen scrapes that mimic human reading are fully automated, and the robots hoovering up the information are not surveilling for new digital services. They’re indiscriminately looking for any kind of text, regardless of source, quality, veracity, or intent. Indeed, the entire internet is the training ground and the raw material for a new kind of application: large language models or LLMs.
Read the full article in Quillette.
More from CNAS
-
Video
Technology & National Security
Russia Ramps Up Drone War With New Launch MegabaseSatellite images show Russia building a major drone launch facility capable of deploying large numbers of jet-powered drones. Analyst Samuel Bendett explains the military impl...
By Samuel Bendett
-
Commentary
Technology & National Security
Sharper: Countering Cyber ThreatsAdvanced AI and quantum capabilities are increasing the cyber threat to critical systems, making the development of proper resilience and responses a national security imperat...
By Charles Horn & Cadence Barker
-
Podcast
Technology & National Security
Spies, Satellites & Startups: Intel in the Digital AgeDr. Anthony Vinci, adjunct senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security and the first Chief Technology Officer and Associate Director for Capabilities at the Nation...
By Anthony Vinci
-
Congressional Testimony
Technology & National Security
A.I. Is Lying to You. Here’s How to Fight Back.A recent study in the scientific journal Nature showed that A.I. dialogue is roughly four times as persuasive as traditional political ads....
By Anthony Vinci
