March 02, 2015

Better Than the Alternatives

By Ilan Goldenberg

The Obama administration is pursuing an imperfect deal with Iran, but one that is far superior to any of the realistic alternatives. Critics argue that instead of the current approach, the United States should pursue a policy that leaves Iran with no nuclear capabilities. Such an outcome would be ideal, but it is impossible to achieve. The issue of nuclear enrichment has become a question of national pride for Iran – a nation that in the past has refused to submit to international pressure in the face of an eight-year war with Iraq that led to the deaths of hundreds of thousands. Iranian surrender is simply not a realistic option.

This means that the only alternative to an agreement is a return to the conflict and sanctions that existed before the nuclear negotiations began. If the talks collapse, the United States will impose tougher sanctions and Iran will restart its nuclear program, which has been frozen for the past year. Very soon the United States may be forced to choose between military action that could result in a major regional war or the equally unappealing option of allowing Iran to become a nuclear weapons state.

Read the full response in U.S. News and World Report.

  • Reports
    • March 29, 2023
    Disarming the Bomb

    Negotiations to return to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), known commonly as the Iran nuclear deal, reached an impasse this past year. Further, Iran made parall...

    By Jonathan Lord, Arona Baigal, Hunter Streling & LCDR Stewart Latwin

  • Commentary
    • The Hill
    • August 21, 2022
    The greatest obstacle to returning to the Iran deal isn’t Iran—it’s Congress

    Leaving the JCPOA may have cost us the most precious commodity: time. And now, out of time, out of options, it’s hard to see how we’re better off. Let Congress consider that....

    By Jonathan Lord

    • Commentary
    • Global Security Review
    • March 15, 2022
    A New Nuclear Deal With Iran Shouldn’t Be Accompanied By Terrorist Legitimization

    Removing the label of terrorism should take effort on behalf of the offending party, something the Islamic Republic is unwilling to provide....

    By John O'Malley

    • Podcast
    • July 2, 2021
    Iran Deal Return Increasingly Uncertain

    Elisa Catalano Ewers joins The Warcast to discuss the series of strikes exchanged in Iraq and Syria and their diplomatic ramifications. Listen to the full episode from The Wa...

    By Elisa Catalano Ewers

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia