October 04, 2017

Worries about Trump’s Generals Are Overblown

It seems that President Trump’s reliance upon retired and active-duty generals in staffing the upper echelons of his administration has raised concerns among a large number of well-informed people. 

With retired Marine general John Kelly serving as White House chief of staff, retired Marine general James Mattis serving as secretary of defense, and Lieutenant General H. R. McMaster serving as national-security adviser, charges are being levied that the nation has embarked down a dangerous path. Some feel that the abundance of retired military officers in high-level government positions undermines the “non-partisan nature of the military” and decreases the public’s trust in its armed forces. Others are of the opinion that Trump’s reliance on military men will “throw off the balance of a system that for good reason favors civilian leadership.” These criticisms are relatively mild in comparison with those levied in the Boston Globe by journalist and academic Stephen Kinzer, who charges that Kelly, Mattis, and McMaster make up a modern military junta in the halls of the White House.

Read the full op-ed in National Review.

  • Podcast

    Defense

    Defense & Aerospace Air Power Podcast: Global View

    In a week when airpower news came from every angle, Becca Wasser, CNAS adjunct senior fellow, was on top of it all. She leads defense research at Bloomberg Economics, and we c...

    By Becca Wasser

    • January 15, 2026
  • Podcast

    Defense

    Balance of Power: Powell Probe Sparks GOP Backlash

    President Donald Trump faced rare opposition from key Republican lawmakers after Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell accused the Department of Justice of launching a grand jur...

    By Becca Wasser

    • January 12, 2026
  • Commentary

    Defense

    The Venezuela Blockade

    Roxanna Vigil, Council on Foreign Relations International Affairs Fellow, talks about President Donald Trump's order to blockade sanctioned oil tankers in Venezuela, and the r...

    By Becca Wasser

    • December 17, 2025
  • Video

    Defense

    The Astronomical Cost of Defeating ‘Any Foreign Aerial Attack’

    Building Trump’s proposed missile and air defense system would be an enormous task — and the president’s spending target is likely just a fraction of the final price. CNAS adj...

    By Becca Wasser

    • December 12, 2025

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia